#1 in Rural Real Estate Online
Cabelas HPBA-Right Column LONY National Land Realty

Land for sale in Cattaraugus County New York - Page 1 of 2

15 photos
$249,900 101.14 acres
Route 242 and Tyler Whitmore Road, Randolph, NY 14772 - Cattaraugus County

Carver's Forest and Farmland

New York land with timber and maintained farmland for Sale:This fantastic property is nearly a 50-50 mix of maintained farm fields and forest. The fields have been rented for many years, primarily for hay production. There are any number of quality building sites on the open field areas as the fields all directly adjoin the highways. The forest area has been managed for timber over the years and has a quality stocking that is mostly cherry with some soft maple, red oak, hickory, ash and hemlock as well. The timber alone is worth nearly half the asking price! Timber was marked for sale in orange paint in 2015 but was not sold. The marked trees are still evident in the forest. Access is excellent throughout the property on a network of intern
Brian Bullard Timberland Realty
23 photos
$181,212 3 acres 5 Beds | 1 Bath | 2600 sqft
3530 Five Mile Road, Allegany, NY 14716 - Cattaraugus County

Five Mile Farmette

New York historic home with barn for Sale: This historic home on 3 acres built in 1916 exemplifies "old world" craftsmanship. With 5 full bedrooms, one and a half baths, and a large kitchen, it's perfect for a family. A formal dining room and large family room with wood burning fireplace is great for entertaining or just relaxing. Incredible woodwork is evident throughout. From beautiful hardwood floors to unique built-in cabinetry and a gorgeous solid wood staircase the quality is unparalleled. Heat is provided by a fuel oil fired boiler and cast iron radiators. Private water and septic are on site.  Outside this home you will find a massive (over 6000 sq. ft.) old barn that's in really nice shape overall. Built in about 1930, they didn't
David Anderson Timberland Realty
15 photos
$109,999 50 acres
end of North Kings Highway, Cattaraugus, NY 14719 - Cattaraugus County

Secluded Nature Sanctuary

New York land for sale: The property is located at the end of Kings Highway North within what is known as the Zaepfel Nature Sanctuary & Research Center. There is a locked gate at the entrance to this 50 acre parcel.  Electric is not available at the road front.  Current cost to bring power to the property is estimated at $9,000-$12,000. This is a unique opportunity to own 50 acres and have access to more than 700 acres for hunting, fishing, trapping, birding, nature study and much, much more.  The area is teaming with wildlife and unique flora and fauna.  The 700+ acres are a nature preserve, conserved for its unique wetland area (547 acres) and associated habitat.  Among the activities available annually to the few landowners within o
Brian Bullard Timberland Realty
9 photos
$87,900 78.45 acres
Crosby Road, Olean, NY 14760 - Cattaraugus County

Hinsdale Hunting

New York completely wooded land with great hunting for sale:  If quiet seclusion along with a great place to hunt, hike, ATV or just plain relax is what you are looking for, then you are in the right place.  This property is completely wooded with a nice mix of maple, ash, cherry, oak, hemlock, white pine, beech, and more.  No timber harvesting has been done in a long time, so the forest is well-stocked and the wildlife is abundant.  Old roads within the property provide access, but because this property has been left in a natural state for many years, some clearing of trails is necessary.  This unspoiled nature is a big part of the attraction of this property, making it easy to take it and make it your own-the way you want it.  There are m
Brian Bullard Timberland Realty
6 photos
$83,900 103.03 acres
Gleason Hollow Road, Portville, NY 14770 - Cattaraugus County

Round Top

New York wooded land with trails for sale:  This 103+ acre property is the perfect hunting, camping and ATV riding getaway.  With an extensive road system throughout the piece, it is very accessible.  A beautiful campsite and roadway was just constructed at the very top of the hill, and with the leaves off the panoramic view is awesome.  The property is almost completely wooded and the timber was recently harvested to 14 inches in diameter. The remaining stand consists of hard and soft maple, red oak and ash and would make a nice long term timber investment.  A small stream meanders through the eastern portion of the land and electric is available at the road in the southeast portion of the property.  Plenty of wildlife calls this piece hom
David Anderson Timberland Realty
2 photos
$17,900 0.23 acres
off Route 16, Hinsdale, NY 14743 - Cattaraugus County

Hinsdale Hideaway

New York lot with cabin for sale:  Located in Hinsdale, New York this property was developed for people to get away and enjoy the country.  This cabin is tucked far into the forest.  There is a small solar electric panel set up to give some power, a fresh water spring feeds water and a wood stove to keep you warm during the colder months.  There is propane service available as well.  The main level is an open area with a kitchen, living area, bedroom, screened in porch and there is a bathroom there as well.  There is a loft with sleeping quarters upstairs and comes with all furnishings.  The cabin sits on a 62' x 165' lot.
Shane Vogel Timberland Realty
19 photos
$995,000 180.8 acres 3 Beds | 2 Baths | 2128 sqft
6415 Rt. 242 East/219 South (E. Washington Street), Ellicottville, NY 14731 - Cattaraugus County

180.8 acres Ellicottville, NY

Rare opportunity for 180+ serene acres adjacent to the Village of Ellicottville consisting of 4 parcels that may be sold separately. Portions are zoned for various commercial, high and/or medium density residential uses with sewer/ water available. 700' of frontage on Rt. 242/219 with farmhouse, barns, and bridge across Great Valley Creek leads to @ 28 flat acres prime for development within short walk to Village. The 150+ acres on the North face of Bartlett Hill with access off Whitmer Rd. offers endless options. Price reduced - all reasonable offers will be considered!
$460,000 5 acres 5 Beds | 4 Baths | 3000 sqft
7061 Mill Valley Rd. #8 Road, East Otto, NY 14729 - Cattaraugus County

5 acres East Otto, NY

Truly a lifestyle legacy purchase!! Join the growing number of homeowners in Ellicottville's hottest new development minutes from the slopes! Lofty Mountain Grandeur #8 is under construction and ready for your family. All chalets feature 5 acre lots and access to groomed nature trails, private fishing ponds, and picnic shelters. Experience the most stunning views in the Southern Tier from your newly built chalet. Chalets are finished with timber accents inside and out with 3000 sq/ft on 3 levels, cutting edge finishes, wide plank floors, and re-claimed wood cabinetry. A four season's family retreat. Phase 1 Bailey Hill SOLD OUT! Rainbow Ridge Lot #8 Phase 2 now under construction and for sale. Get in early and pick your OWN finishes!
$406,999 5 acres 4 Beds | 3 Baths | 2500 sqft
7061 Mill Valley Rd. Lot #15, Ellicottville, NY 14729 - Cattaraugus County

5 acres Ellicottville, NY

Truly a lifestyle legacy purchase!!Join the growing number of homeowners in Ellicottville's hottest new development minutes from the slopes! Lot #15 is under construction & ready for your family!!! All chalets feature a 5 acre lot & access to groomed nature trails, private fishing ponds,& picnic shelters.Experience the most beautiful views in the Southern Tier from your newly built chalet.Chalets are finished with timber accents in the great room & exterior w/3000 sq/ft on 3 levels, cutting edge finishes, wide plank floors,& re-claimed wood cabinetry.
$349,000 17.19 acres 3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1422 sqft
6760 Schwartz Road, Ashford, NY 14171 - Cattaraugus County

17.19 acres Ashford, NY

Contemporary 3 bdrm 2 bath, wooded lot, 2 bdrm guest house above, pond, All just minutes to Springville and Ellicottville. 15 minutes to Hamburg via 219. Room sizes and interior pics to follow. Exterior being re-stained. Newer mechanicals. Separate septic and well for the main house and for the studio/guest. Sq.ftg. shown does not reflect finished bsmt or finished studio above garage. Tenant in house has 30 day termination clause in lease.
$275,000 170 acres 5 Beds | 2 Baths
3035 Creek Road, Hinsdale, NY 14727 - Cattaraugus County

170 acres Hinsdale, NY

This was a former dairy farm but now operated as a beef/crop operation. Approx. 1/3 of the acreage is crop and the balance is wooded. According to owner there is approx. $20,000 of marketable timber on site. Buildings include a large 2 story 2 family farmhouse, a large 2 story barn with a attached garage/shop and several other outbuildings. GOM rights are negotiable. Price just reduced and owner wants offers.
$225,000 5 acres 2 Beds | 2 Baths | 2480 sqft
140 North 3rd Street, Allegany, NY 14706 - Cattaraugus County

5 acres Allegany, NY

This "one of a kind" home is situated on a large 5 acre secluded lot overlooking the village with access over a winding paved drive. This home has been updated, well maintained and is in a move-in condition.
$159,900 48.73 acres 4 Beds | 2 Baths | 1864 sqft
7709 Route 353, New Albion, NY 14719 - Cattaraugus County

48.73 acres New Albion, NY

A breath-taking home on 48+ wooded acres! A MUST SEE home to appreciate its size and beautiful amenities! Tastefully remodeled top to bottom (flooring, ceilings, walls, windows, furnace, hot water heater, etc). Family room features vaulted ceiling and heated floor that leads to laundry room/half bathroom. Sprawling eat-in kitchen is adorned with custom Amish built oak cabinetry, gleaming hardwood floors, and tongue and groove pine ceiling! Formal dining room opens to a cozy living room. Master bedroom with HUGE closet, full bathroom, and second bedroom complete the first floor! Second story features two generously sized bedrooms and open sitting area! Relax in the hot tub on your stamped concrete patio overlooking backyard and woods! Oversi
$157,500 3.07 acres 3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1840 sqft
5659 Windfall Road, Carrollton, NY 14748 - Cattaraugus County

3.07 acres Carrollton, NY

A truly charming country ranch on 3+ acres! This 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom home will have you feeling like you're looking at a home from the Better Homes & Gardens magazine with its cozy, rustic dcor! Large, eat-in kitchen with walk-in pantry and granite breakfast bar with views of your backyard! Spacious living room sets the stage for entertaining family and friends! Beautiful master suite with private bathroom and large walk-in closet! Two additional generously sized bedrooms each with ample storage space will have your kids loving their new rooms! Many updates including septic, furnace, hot water heater, flooring, etc! A great find for those seeking peace and quiet!
15 photos
$154,900 12.65 acres 5 Beds | 2 Baths | 2184 sqft
9400 Wickham Road, Otto, NY 14719 - Cattaraugus County

12.65 acres Otto, NY

This Charming historic property is a Red Brick Colonial home sits on over 12 acres of beautiful land surrounded by state land with black walnut, hickory, apple, red cedar and more woods!! Great property, is a hunters paradise an herbalists dream! This house would make a great B&B or perfect for anyone who's looking for room to spread out! Updates include electric updated to 200 amp service , New hard wired electric Base board heat, great hardwood floors and natural woodwork, hot tub,Large 40x30 pole barn. Also Three wood burning stoves. This home is part of the original Hill Dairy farm. Deep Stone Foundation, Lovingly restored and maintained. The owners are only the 2nd family to own in 157 Years. All this and more. Call for an appointme
$149,900 6.8 acres 3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1584 sqft
3965 Riceville Road, Machias, NY 14101 - Cattaraugus County

6.8 acres Machias, NY

Move right in! This three bedroom, 2 bath home is on nearly 7 acres and has been completely updated. Improvements include new furnace, hot water tank, basement drain tile, yard drainage, updated plumbing, updated first floor bath, updated flooring and many new windows. Oversized 1+ garage is heated, insulated and has drywall- perfect for a workshop! Other features include second floor laundry, solid metal roof and maintenance free exterior. Great room sizes and storage. Picturesque private setting and a beautiful view from the back deck! Minutes from Lime Lake, shopping, and schools. This is a must see. Call for a private showing today!
$145,900 3.5 acres 3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1176 sqft
9259 Route 98, Farmersville, NY 14737 - Cattaraugus County

3.5 acres Farmersville, NY

This listing is new to the market and consists of a 3br 2ba bungalo sited on 3+ acres just north of Franklinville. Also on site is a 2 car detached garage, a large barn, a in-ground pool and pond. Indicated taxes are estimated since this is part of a larger parcel to be surveyed off. A adjoining 3+ acre parcel is available for an additional $10,000. Must be seen to be appreciated.
$145,000 25.8 acres 3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1280 sqft
8185 Otto Road, East Otto, NY 14729 - Cattaraugus County

25.8 acres East Otto, NY

Nature at its best on 25.8 picturesque acres!Almost completely wooded, with wide range of terrain features, abundant wildlife-very peaceful area-has something for everyone. Ideal for the avid sportsman offering hunting, hiking, recreation, with scenic views thruout. Included is 2004 manufactured home, approx 1300 sq ft, on a full foundation (8' bsmt). This property offers 3 bedrooms,walk-in closets in all, 2 full baths, living/dining/kitchen combo. Half the roof a complete tear-off (2016),new skylights, septic serviced 2008. Property is close to amenities, full of young & mature trees. All GOM & timber rights go with the sale. All appliances (except the freezer) are included, as well as the TV, should buyer choose. All this home needs is co
6 photos
$134,900 4.49 acres 4 Beds | 2 Baths | 1400 sqft
5096 Bigelow Road, Ashford, NY 14171 - Cattaraugus County

4.49 acres Ashford, NY

Nice country home on almost 5 acres! Well kept 4 bedroom, 2 bath ranch featuring country kitchen, living room, back deck, covered front porch and full high basement with walkout. Newer roof, a few new carpets and much more. Plenty of room for the kids to play. Interior pictures not included at request of owner. Very nice home, take a look for yourself! Owners will look at all offers.
2 photos
$129,900 77 acres
0 Wardtown Road, Perrysburg, NY 14129 - Cattaraugus County

77 acres Perrysburg, NY

Take a look at this 77 acre property with over 3,000 ft in frontage. Property is on a quite road, close to amenities, and full of mature trees. This is a great spot for hunting, recreation, weekend trips, or to build your new home on. Property has a gas well that gives royalties and could have free gas for house. There is also another 23 acres available, please call for details.
$99,900 2.45 acres 2 Beds | 1 Bath | 1080 sqft
7466 Dublin Road, Salamanca, NY 14779 - Cattaraugus County

2.45 acres Salamanca, NY

The price of this quaint 2 bedroom cottage has been reasonably reduced. Built in a country setting it offers a large yard along with a covered patio and plenty of room for parking for those who enjoy entertaining. Located within 2 minutes of the village of EVL and 2 nationally known ski resorts, it is also in close proximity to H.V. and Elkdale country club golf courses. In the other direction, ten minutes to the Seneca Allegany Casino and Allegany State Park.
$99,900 4.45 acres 3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1215 sqft
6257 Sullivan Hollow Road, Great Valley, NY 14748 - Cattaraugus County

4.45 acres Great Valley, NY

This solid 3 bedroom ranch on 4.45 acres is just the right size! Large eat-in kitchen offers plenty of cabinet and counter space! Spacious living room has pine wood floors underneath carpeting. Three bedrooms each with closet space and plenty of room! Full basement offers potential to be finished into an awesome family/rec room! Two enclosed porches and back patio add to the charm of this home! Blacktop driveway leads to a two car garage! Sprawling parcel of land with lots of frontage! Apple, pear, peach, plum trees, and grapevines abound on this beautiful country estate!
10 photos
$84,900 51.2 acres 1116 sqft
9380 Harvey Road, East Otto, NY 14719 - Cattaraugus County

51.2 acres East Otto, NY

These 51+ picturesque acreage have it all - hunters dream or build your dream home!! Woods with hickory, walnut & cherry trees and more, pond, some DEC designated wetlands with fish duck and all kids of wildlife, food plots planted around the land and more with this beautiful country setting!!
$84,900 6.95 acres 2 Beds | 1 Bath | 1520 sqft
5908 Humphrey Road, Great Valley, NY 14731 - Cattaraugus County

6.95 acres Great Valley, NY

A very solid built house with lots of potential, just needs a little TLC. Original wood floors. Kitchen cupboards are made from hickory and were hand crafted by the Amish approximately 10 years ago. A sweeping, panoramic view of beautiful downtown Great Valley and the surrounding area.
$80,000 57 acres
242 Nys Route 242, Napoli, NY 14755 - Cattaraugus County

57 acres Napoli, NY

57 acres!!! Small cabin with electric, wood burning stove. Enjoy recreational activities with this large nice parcel.
$79,900 5.05 acres 3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1170 sqft
3549 Hilltop Lane, Franklinville, NY 14737 - Cattaraugus County

5.05 acres Franklinville, NY

Looking for a get-away to enjoy ATV's, Snowmobiling, Hunting or all round enjoying nature at its best! Owners are sacrificing this affordable 5 acre country retreat close to State land that can be a year round home for the person who wants their privacy. Fully furnished 3 bedroom double wide with almost 1200 sq ft. Updates within the last 10 years include: New furnace and ductwork throughout, laminate flooring and carpeting, newer bath, updated plumbing and electrical, some drywall, insulated underneath of home. Back room is a nice mud room, front other room is mechanical room that used to have laundry. Great neighbors, privacy, peaceful, fully furnished...a real deal, call today!
$79,900 5.5 acres
Vl ALDRICH EXT., Persia, NY 14070 - Cattaraugus County

5.5 acres Persia, NY

This 11.2 acre lot combines both ML B505133 & B505134. Public water & sewer at road, open in the front with trees in the back.
$79,900 71.75 acres
0 Lippert Hollow Road, Allegany, NY 14706 - Cattaraugus County

71.75 acres Allegany, NY

This large wooded land parcel is located just south of Olean. Was timbered several years ago. Would make a great recreational site. Owner believes GOM rights are intact and if so, will transfer.
$77,600 97 acres 217800 sqft
0 4th Street, Little Valley, NY 14755 - Cattaraugus County

97 acres Little Valley, NY

A little piece of heaven just 15 minutes from Ellicottville! Enjoy the serenity of 97 wooded acres. Ideal for camping, 4-wheeling, hunting or hiking. Hard woods as well as natural springs await you. Best of all you are right next to State land!
$69,900 102 acres
Vl Nys Route 16, Allegany, NY 14706 - Cattaraugus County

102 acres Allegany, NY

Reduced for a quick sale, 102 ACRES HILLSIDE WOODED ACRES W/A AWESOME VIEW, NEXT TO ROCK CITY PARK!! HUNT/RECREATION/OR BUILD YOU DREAM HOME WITH A AWESOME VIEW... MORE ACRES AVAILABLE on the other side of the road: Timber rights transfer to new owner. Make an offer Today! FOR AVAILABLE ADJACENT LOTS SEE ML B473208 & B473209